- Two years after taking Pocketpair to court, Nintendo's legal battle against Palworld has become increasingly complicated, with patent rejections, gameplay changes, and a potentially much smaller financial victory than expected.
- By the end of February 2024, it had sold 15 million copies on Steam and attracted a further 10 million players on Xbox.
- Update 0.5 in May 2025 later disabled this ability, requiring players to use regular gliders to glide with Pals.
- Meanwhile, Palworld has kept growing since its initial release.
Two years after taking Pocketpair to court, Nintendo's legal battle against Palworld has become increasingly complicated, with patent rejections, gameplay changes, and a potentially much smaller financial victory than expected.
When Palworld launched in January 2024, Palworld became a gaming sensation. Japanese studio Pocketpair’s survival game drew attention for its strange blend of creature collection, open-world exploration, crafting, and weapon-based combat. Its resemblance to Pokémon also became a major talking point, with many players instantly calling it Pokémon with guns.
However, the game’s remarkable success soon drew the attention of Nintendo and The Pokémon Company, leading to a legal struggle that has raged for nearly two years. Palworld’s success was practically instantaneous. The game sold one million copies in its first eight hours, two million copies in one day, and eight million copies in just six days.
By the end of February 2024, it had sold 15 million copies on Steam and attracted a further 10 million players on Xbox.
At its peak, it had over 2.1 million concurrent players on Steam, making it one of the platform's biggest launches. Palworld sold well but has been criticized for the similarity between some of its creatures and Pokémon designs. Online users also claimed that some of the 3D models had been copied, but these claims were never legally substantiated. Pocketpair CEO Takuro Mizobe defended the designs, saying legal counsel had reviewed them.
Nintendo and The Pokémon Company officially filed a lawsuit against Pocketpair on September 19, 2024, at the Tokyo District Court. Surprisingly, the issue was not about copyright infringement or purportedly cloned creature designs. Instead, Nintendo targeted several patents on gameplay concepts, such as throwing an item at a creature to catch it, calculating whether an encounter results in capture or conflict, and riding creatures around an open area.
Nintendo sought an injunction to halt the alleged infringement and demanded five million yen from each company, for a total of 10 million yen, or about $65,000 at the time. Pocketpair said it was disappointed by the case and was not notified of the specific patents before the legal action. Later, patent watchers questioned the patents' timeliness, saying some were submitted and granted after Palworld's release.

Nintendo has purportedly linked them to an earlier 2021 filing through divisional papers, but the corporation has not publicly disclosed its broader legal strategy. Pocketpair didn't just rely on the courtroom battle to change Palworld's gameplay. The option to throw a Pal Sphere to directly call a Pal into battle was disabled in Update 0.3.11, released on November 30, 2024. Instead, mobs would just spawn next to the player.
Update 0.5 in May 2025 later disabled this ability, requiring players to use regular gliders to glide with Pals.
Pocketpair said they were disappointed, but it was important to continue developing the game, and they publicly admitted these adjustments were related to the litigation. There were also reports in late 2025 that Nintendo and The Pokémon Company had limited their legal claims to earlier versions of Palworld released before these changes.
The same thing happened in the US. The US Patent and Trademark Office Director, John Squires, ordered a reexamination of a Nintendo invention related to summoning characters and letting them fight. On April 1, 2026, the examiner rejected all 26 patent claims. The judgment was not definitive, but Nintendo had the chance to respond. Another application related to creature-catching mechanics on touchscreens was apparently rejected in May 2026 as well.
But Nintendo's case in Tokyo is independent of those US patent judgments, even if it has suffered some legal setbacks. Patent analysts monitoring the dispute have pointed to potential damages of around five million yen, or approximately $30,000. Their projection supposedly accounts for only a short period of Japanese sales in 2024 before Pocketpair made the gameplay improvements. This is an analyst estimate, not a figure recognized by a court.

Meanwhile, Palworld has kept growing since its initial release.
Pocketpair also partnered with Sony Music and Aniplex to handle goods and licensing, and launched a mobile version with PUBG Studios. By early 2025, the game had grown to over 32 million users and eventually reached version 1.0 across PC, Xbox, and PlayStation in July 2026.
The Tokyo court convened an evidence hearing on October 1, but no publicly acknowledged verdict has been released, despite an earlier expectation of an opinion around November 9. At present, Pocketpair has altered two key gameplay elements, Nintendo has reduced its claims, and patent offices in Japan and the United States have disputed multiple Nintendo patent applications related to the case. However, this does not mean Nintendo has lost the case.






